So: With Valentine’s Day approaching, we’re pretty sure that people are thinking more about underwear (“lingerie”) than normal. We have been, in any case, and, as we mentioned in this post about the awesome Journelle, trying to go slightly outside our comfort zone (read: shopping somewhere other than Victoria’s Secret). What we have discovered (“cage panties”) has shocked and sometimes scared us, but has also shown enough new things—things we have never even heard of before—that we thought we would catalogue them from “nice to naughty,” with sexy grades provided (in most cases) by the male source we had closest to hand.

Screen shot 2013-02-01 at 8.04.42 AM

To be honest, we spend most of our waking hours in Gap Body cotton, because…just because, really. The funny thing is that we can’t even find the ones that are as boring (read: one color) as the ones we like.
Sexy grade: Our source says A, because guys are weird, and because, really, there’s something very positive about being low-fuss, low-muss people.

Screen shot 2013-02-01 at 8.55.40 AM

Isn’t this the thong that everyone has? These or the Hanky Panky ones? Cosabella Never Say Never Cutie thong, $20
Sexy grade: Our male source says these are too commonplace to be interesting, and we’ll take his word on it. C+.

Screen shot 2013-02-01 at 9.01.06 AM

We recently saw a movie called Concussion (it’s great!) at Sundance, and people in the audience literally gasped when the heroine kneeled down, and you could see her wearing garters. Gasped! Do people not wear these enough anymore? These are Agent Provocateur lacy suspenders, $190
Sexy grade: A.

Damaris strip knickers

We are so, so glad we were able to find a picture of what these look like without someone wearing them, because that’s just too much for our prude ways. (Here’s a link to one—and it’s only $11.95!) Damaris’s Zanzibar lace strip knickers, $132
Sexy grade: Our male source says, “A++++.” We feel like they’d be hard to, like, actually wear, so we’re pushing this down to a B+. We maintain: Comfort counts in sexy grades!

cara-brief-01

This looks a bit boring from the front, but the back actually snaps up. It’s a little try-hard/50 Shades of Grey weekend, if you ask us, but okay. Lascivious Cara briefs, about $100
Sexy grade: B.

Screen shot 2013-02-01 at 9.15.24 AM

Something about these strike us as funny, and funny is so obviously not the key to sexy Valentine’s Day lingerie but maybe sort of is the key, too, if you follow us. Damaris fringed knickers, $
Sexy grade: A

We used to work in the same building, more or less, as the Journelle on Mercer Street, and to get home expeditiously (or, at least, get to the APC/Georgetown Cupcakes), we’d need to walk past Journelle. We swear to God, sometimes we’d just stare in the windows because everything was so, so pretty. But the reality was that when we needed new bras, we’d always end up going to Victoria’s Secret, even though we know it is the McDonald’s of underthings.

We had it in our mind that the actually really nice underwear at Journelle was too expensive to afford. Then, one very important day, we realized that we were completely wrong, and that while there are plenty of — let’s say, special occasion pieces — there are also plenty of things that are both (a) nicer and (b) cheaper than VS. It’s a win-win! We were a little sad for not having figured it out earlier. Maybe it’s because they (and their brands) spend so much less money on Gisele Bundchen.

Above: the Eberjay Theodora bralet, $49

This is quite small. Maison Close Villa Satine triangle bra, $64.90

This is a very V-Day sort of color. Stella McCartney Julia Tumbling bra, $85

This is more on the special-occasion end of things. Myla Rita Underwire Apex bra, $149

This has matching garters, which is a bonus. We’re seeing 2013 as a very pro-garters sort of year. Chantelle Eternelle demi bra, $105

This is proof that we’ll love a galaxy print on absolutely anything, because we are so not about amazing sheer kimonos. But if we were, this would so obviously be the one.

The great challenge with Valentine’s Day, in our opinion, is to get through it while not going to Victoria’s Secret. Right? There is nowhere better to start looking than La Fee Verte, the Canadian lingerie maker. Everything they do is gorgeous.

La Fee Verte kimono, $240