
You may be thinking: Wow. There is a ridiculous amount of food to eat at the holidays. We hear you. There is usually not very much food to eat in our apartment, seeing as we spend most of our time out of it—except on Sundays, when we go to Mazzola Bakery in Carroll Gardens and bring home as many cookies as we can carry.
This is perhaps the worst-possible introduction for our post today on P90X versus Insanity.
If you’re looking for a present this holiday season that will help you get fit and deal with (a) holiday food overload or (b) cookies and Wheat Thins, we so heartily recommend P90X. We have written about it previously, and we love it. You may know this if you watch the infomercial every morning on Comedy Central while getting dressed (like we do), but P90X is a 90-day program with a weekly plan of three weight workouts, two cardio, and Yoga X, which is impossible for a lot of the jacked-up dudes who complain about it on the message boards and pretty easy if you’ve ever done yoga in the past. After doing it pretty steadily (even while more or less ignoring the eating plan, which does not include cookies), we literally had a rash of people (including two massage therapists, while working on the best story ever) saying to us earlier this year that we were “fit.” We swear to God: We thought, the first couple times, that they were making fun of us. Then we realized: P90X was working! Even if we still had our Sunday afternoon cookie runs.
We realized, though, that we tended to follow a pattern: We’d stick pretty religiously to the three weight workouts, but the two cardio ones … meh. One of them is “Plyometrics” (“jump-training”) and we found this difficult to do simply because we live in an apartment building, and the downstairs people, we felt, did not deserve an hour of us jumping on their heads. So we’d go to the gym and use the elliptical or we’d run, while watching Survivor. We weren’t making much real headway here. More often than not, we’d skip the cardio. Disaster!
That is, until we saw the ads (because we love those infomercials) for Insanity. Led by Shaun T., Insanity is made up of super-intense cardio workouts. So we did a quick Google search for hybrid P90X/Insanity workouts, and put them together. They are like PB+J. Or two other things that go even better together. They’re harder (at least for us newbies), but they’re shorter (around 45 minutes, while a P90X leg workout is closer to 1:15, from warm up to cool down.)
If you’re only going to get one, we’d say strongly: Go with P90X. (Or P90X2, which will be out in time for Christmas.) We love Tony Horton, who leads the P90X videos. You just—well, we do—absolutely believe him when he tells beginners to “press pause—we’ll be here when you get back.” We found both of these workouts super-hard in the early days, and that makes a difference. Shaun T. says the same sort of stuff, but you sort of think he’ll think you’re a pussy if you do. It seems like a small thing, but in P90X, Tony shares the set with three or four other work-outers, so you can see their form. (These include the awesome Dreya Weber.) On Insanity, a couple of the models who are featured prominently go through the workouts just totally hamming it up, like—this is the face I make when it’s really hard, this is the face I make now. It’s kind of annoying.
Insanity does have some big pros: It’s easier to travel with, because you really don’t need any additional equipment. It’s shorter. And we think we actually saw results faster with Insanity, in terms of an demonstrable improvement in our fitness level. We occasionally have caffeine-induced episodes of heart racing—we noticed these have stopped since we added Insanity to our workout schedule. It’s officially only 60 days—but hopefully it’s not like you’d get to the end and just quit, so whatevs on that one.
Still, our heart belongs to P90X, and it’s the glue that holds our fitness life together. It’s pricey, but if one of your resolutions is to get fit, we heartily recommend it. Stick with it, and it’ll work, and isn’t that all we can ask of our fitness programs?
Above: Lululemon Herringbone Define Jacket, $108. Here’s the thing: Everyone says P90X is expensive, and it is, but it’s not much more than this jacket.