
In today's Answer Guy:
Q: I just moved from BFE to the City to be with my boyfriend, whose female friends, I've discovered, are all obnoxious fashion girls. I could give a shit about fashion, I certainly am not spending the bulk of my paycheck on it, and I have no desire to be one of those vapid, insipid, entitled empty vessels. Still, I can't help but wonder if he likes them or wants me to dress/be more like them. Help?
A: There are really two options here in evaluating your boyfriend's relationship with his female friends: he is not fucking them because 1), he doesn't want to, or 2), they don't want to. Well, hmmm. AG has mostly female friends, and while most of them fall into one of those categories, it leaves a few who fit into two lesser categories: 3) they haven't got that desperate, YET, or 4) AG hasn't got that desperate, YET. So, with a small sampling of some of AG's straight guy friends, our female friends fall into the above categories in the following percentages, with some fairly liberal rounding:
Boy doesn't want (may or may not indicate that Girl doesn't want as well): 50%
Girl doesn't want (Boy does want): 40%
Girl is not desperate enough (Boy is or has been): 5%
Boy is not desperate enough: 5% (This is crudely known, to at least one boy, as the emergency landing strip).
The really interesting thing is that the answers changed when the boys were asked how they would describe the distribution to their significant others:
Boy doesn't want: 80%
Girl doesn't want: 0%
Girl is not desperate enough: 0%
Boy is not desperate enough: 20%
As much as that might seem like a tangent, this is important stuff. If you are what the boy wants, and he is not interested in the fahsion girls, worrying about this is going to cause problems. That said, you're not going to get an honest answer out of your boy about his level of interest in his female friends. He will deny, deny, deny. He may admit that she's attractive, but will almost certainly follow any statement to that effect with "but I'm just not interested in her like that," possibly followed by some insane justification of his supposed non-interest—AG prefers/recommends: "she's just not you," when backed into this particular corner. This may or may not be true. And if he wants you to look a little bit more like the girls he surrounds himself with (or the significant others of his friends, colleagues, etc), and you ignore that, well, that seems likely to end badly as well. But you probably aren't going to hear it from him, so, yes, you're fucked.
Why are these things so complicated, AG wonders. Really, it is a mystery why we don't know one guy, AG included, who does not lie to his significant other, at least once in a while.
But when it comes to your personal style or lack-there-of, AG is thinking: stick to your guns. You are not going to compete here, mostly because their combination of plentiful dollars and less-plentiful brain cells, when dedicated to fashion, is intended to keep YOU from looking like THEM. Furthermore, you really don't WANT to compete here, and AG instructs you to assume, for your sanity, that the boy wants you because you are YOU, you are different, you are perfect the way you are. If you don't make that assumption, you're likely to make yourself (and your boy) miserable. This is to say: believe what your boyfriend is probably telling you, whether or not he's lying (he is).
On the other hand, if you are/become open to (some) change for the boy (AG hopes you don't), AG would encourage you to make it easy for your boyfriend to admire members of the opposite sex in your presence. After some time, these will give you some indication of what (else) he likes. You can do what you want with this information. But, while AG often gawks at girls somewhat dissimilar to the kinds of girls he finds attractive for relationships, he still doesn't want the girlfriend to change (well, not based on just gawking). AG's guy friends confirm that they also do this, so don't make any dramatic changes before you confirm with the boy. Still, changing for a boy, even if it's just what you're wearing, is a bad idea, and as always, unless stated very clearly, do not expect reciprocity. Find someone who appreciates you as-is.
If it becomes purely a question of money, that is different. For example, if you are amenable to accompanying your boyfriend to an event where stylish attire is required (whether to make your boyfriend, your hosts or yourself comfortable is really beside the point), but you are not in a position to outfit yourself appropriately, well, it is your boyfriend's responsibility; that is, he ponies up. Period. Scratch that (the period). This is also a fantastic opportunity for one of his female friends to step up and offer something in her wardrobe. One tangential but incredibly important rule: return any item of borrowed clothing in the best state possible, dry-cleaned and meticulous, even if it's from your best friend. Deodorant stains, ripped seams, etc, are entirely unacceptable when borrowing.
What AG is noticing, though, is that boyfriends have a way of complimenting girls when they dress ... um, let's say ... differently, that makes them think: so when I'm not all done up, I guess you think I look like shit . Sometimes this is reversed, especially when they (the girl) are often done up, and in this case, they're apt to think: why do I put all the effort in? Really, you can't win. This, AG can only assume from personal experience and extensive anecdotal evidence, is somehow akin to boys thinking they are fucking someone new when their significant other changes their hair color dramatically. Don't take it too personally.
This is not, however, license to wear Birkenstock clogs, or any of the myriad truly awful fashion faux-pas ( e.g., ballet flats on girls who, quite clearly, are not, and never could have been, ballerinas—do not get me started) that are not acceptable anywhere, including BFE.
We just looked up "BFE" and apparently it refers to "bum-fuck Egypt." Fair enough. We will say we have no problem with anyone wearing ballerina flats. We just think, and here we diverge from our Answer Guy, who we have sworn to answer our queries only fully and honestly, that whenever we have worried about what our love interest thinks—in manners like this, rather than matters, like, say, what he wants for Christmas—we are unhappy, and whenever we are blissfully doing our own thing, we are, in fact, blissful. We are sure there is no percentage in anything else. Anything else. We repeat in an effort to achieve force, and conviction. There is no other way.
We open the floor to discussion. We would not change what we wear to please someone else. We will say, though, that we have been inspired, in the past, to wear fewer stained items of clothing to impress someone, someone male, and that, we are going to say with confidence, can be only a good thing.
We welcome further questions for our Answer Guy, who eagerly awaits them.
Recent Comments